Gold $3,866.41Silver $47.53Spot per troy ounce, updated today(346) 461-1051
Call (346) 461-1051
  1. Home
  2. What we buy
  3. Rare and graded coins

Sell rare and graded coins in Houston

Slabbed coins, scarce dates, mint errors and early American coins are priced on what collectors pay for them now.

Get a free written offer

We call back the same business day to set a private appointment.

Rare coins we buy

  • PCGS and NGC graded coins
  • Carson City Morgans and gold
  • Early half cents and large cents
  • Bust and Seated Liberty silver
  • Commemorative half dollars
  • Mint errors and off-center strikes
  • Proof gold and silver
  • Proof and mint state type coins

How rare coins are priced

For graded coins, the holder tells us the grade, and we confirm the coin matches it. Prices come from dealer wholesale sheets, published price guides and recent auction results for the same coin and grade.

Raw coins need grading first, and we do that in front of you. A coin's eye appeal matters as much as the number. Original toning can add value, while cleaning or polishing takes a large share of it away.

Carson City gold coin in a PCGS holder

Selling rare coins in Houston

Houston has a long run of serious collectors. Many of the graded coins we see were bought at coin shows held in the city over the years, and they still carry the old green-label or rattler holders from the 1980s and 1990s. Those older holders sometimes hold coins that would grade higher today.

Texas commemoratives are a local favorite. Collectors here put together sets of the Texas Centennial halves by date and mint mark, often in Capital Plastics holders or old dealer flips. We price those sets as sets when they are complete.

If you think a coin might be an error, keep it out of tumbling jars and coin counters. Off-center strikes, doubled dies and broadstrikes are worth more when the surfaces are untouched.

For a coin worth a lot, we will tell you if a major auction would serve you better. You can take our written offer and compare.

When a coin is worth sending to auction

Some coins are worth more at a major auction than any local buyer can pay. That usually means coins that sell for many thousands of dollars, where a specialist auction draws bidders from around the world. If we think you have one of those, we will say so and explain how consignment works.

For everything else, a local sale is faster and simpler. Auction fees, shipping, insurance and a wait of several months eat into the result on mid-range coins. We put our offer in writing so you can weigh it against what an auction might bring and decide for yourself.

Old holders and crossovers

Houston collectors bought a lot of graded coins in the 1980s and 1990s, and many of those coins still sit in the original holders. Grading standards have shifted since then, and some older holders contain coins that would grade higher today. A few contain coins that would grade lower.

We look at the coin, not just the label. If a coin in an old holder looks undergraded, we will tell you and price it for what it is. If you would rather send it in for a fresh look before selling, we can explain the cost and timing so you can decide if it is worth it.

Rare coins we see in Houston

Houston collections hold more scarce coins than people expect. These are the ones that make us slow down during an appointment.

  • Carson City Morgans and gold, especially in old holders
  • Texas Centennial half dollar sets by date and mint mark
  • Early Bust and Seated Liberty silver from old family collections
  • Proof gold and silver from the Mint
  • Better-date Buffalo nickels and Mercury dimes with full detail
  • Major mint errors such as off-center strikes and doubled dies

Related reading: Texas Centennial half dollar value

Questions sellers ask

Do you pay more for PCGS or NGC coins?

Both services are trusted, and coins in either holder sell well. Prices can differ a little by coin. We price each one on recent sales for that exact coin and grade.

Should I get my coins graded before selling?

Usually not. Grading costs money and takes weeks. We can tell you which coins would gain from grading and which would not.

Do you buy error coins?

Yes. True mint errors sell to specialist collectors. Damage after the coin left the mint is not an error, and we will explain the difference.

Can you tell me if my coin is worth grading?

Yes. We look at the coin and tell you whether grading would likely raise its price by more than the grading fee and shipping. For most coins, it would not.

Do you buy coins in old green-label holders?

Yes. Coins in older holders sell well, and some are undergraded compared with current standards.

Find out what your coins and gold are worth

Book a free, private appraisal anywhere in the Houston area. You get a written offer and there is no charge if you say no.